Does dieting hurt your mental health? Science reveals the truth

You may be losing weight—but at what cost to your mind?

That “healthy” diet you’re following could be silently messing with your mental health. While low-calorie plans are marketed as the fast track to fitness, a new study warns they may actually be fueling depression, anxiety, and emotional burnout, especially when not backed by medical guidance.

In a large-scale study published in BMJ Nutrition, Prevention and Health, researchers found that people following calorie-restricted diets were more likely to report symptoms of depression than those not dieting at all.

What the research uncovered

Scientists analyzed health data from nearly 30,000 people in the U.S. using the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) from 2007–2018. Participants were also assessed using the PHQ-9 depression scale, a standard tool for measuring depressive symptoms.

Key findings included:

• 8% were on calorie-restricted diets
• 8% of all respondents reported depressive symptoms
• Those on low-calorie diets had higher depression scores—especially men and individuals who were overweight but not obese

Even more revealing: nutrient-restricted diets, like those low in carbs, sugar, or sodium, didn’t show the same mental health risks—suggesting cutting calories too aggressively is the real culprit.

Why dieting could be hurting your mental health

Experts say the problem lies in nutrient gaps and lack of support.

“When people cut calories without guidance, they often miss out on essential nutrients that support brain health,” said Dr. Marta Mudd, MD, PhD, a psychiatry expert at McGaw Medical Center of Northwestern University.

According to the study, men on low-calorie diets experienced more physical distress, anxiety, and negative thought patterns than women not dieting.

Dr. Venkat Bhat, study co-author and psychiatrist at St. Michael’s Hospital in Toronto, added that nutritional deficiencies in omega-3s, B vitamins, and protein—critical for brain function—may explain this connection.

Additionally, calorie-restricted diets only tend to improve mental health in controlled environments with structured weight loss and behavioral therapy—not in the real world, where most people diet alone, face weight cycling, or feel discouraged by slow results.

A caution, not a condemnation

The researchers stressed this is an observational study, so it shows a correlation, not causation. But it raises serious questions about how popular diet trends may be doing more harm than good—particularly for mental well-being.

“Weight loss isn’t just a physical journey—it’s an emotional one too,” said Dr. Maryam S. Makowski, clinical associate professor at Stanford University.
 
How to diet without hurting your mind

If you're trying to lose weight, experts say it’s not about avoiding dieting—it's about doing it smartly and safely:

✔️ Choose balanced, sustainable plans over extreme restrictions
✔️ Eat whole, nutrient-rich foods to avoid deficiencies
✔️ Work with professionals who can guide both nutrition and mental health
✔️ Check in with yourself emotionally—mood swings or constant fatigue are red flags

Bottom line

That crash diet may shrink your waistline, but it might also be shrinking your serotonin. If your goal is better health, don’t ignore your mental well-being in the process.

---

CLICK HERE TO FOLLOW Medical News Pakistan for daily science-backed health insights that matter to your body—and your brain.